Best Gluten Free Brownie Mix- Taste Test Update

Best gluten-free brownie from a mix. Our taste test. Who won? Here are the winners.

Gluten Free Brownie Mix Taste Test - The Winner


And the winner is...

Steve and I decided to do a taste test. Our goal? Finding the best tasting gluten-free brownie from a mix. Our criteria? A brownie so abundant in chocolaty goodness it would fool a gluten eater. Steve is the brownie baker in the family, so he was in on this project from the start. 

I had him at, What if...

For the sake of simplicity we chose to compare the three gluten-free mixes readily available at our local markets: Bob's Red Mill Gluten Free Brownie Mix, Pamela's Irresistible Chocolate Brownie Mix, and The Gluten Free Pantry Chocolate Truffle Brownie Mix.

We were most familiar with The Gluten Free Pantry Chocolate Truffle Brownie Mix as it was the first gluten-free mix we tried when we gave up gluten five years ago. It gave us hope. The will to live. Gooey, chocolate goodness.

I suppose I should mention here, in the spirit of full disclosure, we always add extra semi-sweet chocolate chips into our bar and cookie recipes; even if the recipe or mix might not call for chips; and if a recipe or mix does call for chips, we double it. We like our brownies decadent. Life is short.
So, let's get to it.

We began this experiment with Pamela's. Here are our notes.


Pamela's Irresistible Chocolate Brownie Mix

Pros::

Honey and molasses for sweetening - a plus for those limiting sugar intake.

I used cold coffee for the liquid (as directed on the package for a mocha flavor - nice option!) and I thought the balance of chocolate to coffee flavor was perfect, and overall, not too sweet.

The brownies rose high, and had more of a cake-like texture than I expect in a brownie, but I didn't hold that against them. They looked like a true brownie when I took them out of the oven.

Cons::

The mix (as is) needs a smaller pan than my favorite large Chicago Metallic pan.

Baked at sea level [read: humid] the texture was more cakey than chewy-gooey. Because of this, Steve voted these down.

Update note: For some reason, these brownies seem to bake even better in a drier climate. Because we are at high altitude now, I upped the oven temperature to 375 degrees F- as Pamela's suggests for high altitude- and they came out perfect.



Pros::

The Bob's Red Mill mix has a nice look to the packaging; very appealing.

I liked the use of turbinado sugar in the mix, and the Ghiardelli cocoa.

Cons::

An in-between amount of batter and I had to choose between my favorite large brownie pan and the smaller Pyrex; I chose to stretch it and used the big pan, so the brownies were thin. If I were to do it again, I'd try a muffin tin.

The texture was good and slightly chewy, not gooey, but passable.

The flavor was just okay. I'm not a fan of bean flours. There was something missing.

Our overall impression was, well. These taste a tad "gluten-free" and we would not bother making them as a real treat. We doubted a gluten-eater would be enamored.



Pros::

Lots of batter for the buck- enough so that I could use my favorite large brownie pan.

I also appreciate the preparation tip on the bag to line the pan with foil and grease it. This makes clean-up: done.

Hands down the best texture and mouth feel. A perfect balance of chewy and gooey.

We both believe even gluten-eaters would be impressed with these brownies. They look, feel, and taste like a normal brownie living in a gluten filled world.

Steve's number one choice, no contest.

Cons::

No real complaints from me. Pretty darn good. Fudgy.

The winner?

The original winner from December 2005 is pictured above in all its glorious chocolate radiance. It's The Gluten Free Pantry Chocolate Truffle Brownie Mix.


Update 2008:

We now have a two new faves, Dear Gluten-Free Reader. Pamela's Irresistible Chocolate Brownie Mix and Namaste Brownie Mix. We kick 'em up with extras.


Kick Up Your Mix::
  • Substitute the water with coffee, coconut milk, or a safe vanilla non-dairy milk
  • Add a cup of shredded sweetened coconut
  • Add more chips- we add a cup of semi-sweet chocolate chips or try a cup of gluten-free white chocolate chips or even peanut butter chips
  • Add a half cup peanuts, macadamia nuts, pecans or walnuts
  • Go Chunky style- add raisins and chips and peanuts, or Almond Joy style with coconut and toasted almonds
  • With the additions above, you may need to use a larger brownie pan


And if, by any chance, you're feeling up to baking a brownie from scratch...see my divinely delicious dark chocolate brownie recipe.
.

|BAKE SOME MUFFINS$type=two$h=0$meta=0$rm=0$snip=0

|BAKING BREAD$type=left$va=0$count=3

|ALMOND FLOUR$type=right$va=0$count=3

TASTE$type=one$count=1

Name

almond almond flour aphrodisiac appetizer apple artichoke hearts asparagus avocado awareness banana bars beef biscotti biscuits blueberry bones bread breakfast breakfast bars broken hip brownies brunch buckwheat budget cabbage cake carob carrot cashew cream casserole celiac celiac awareness celiac disease cereal cherry chicken chili chocolate chocolate cake chocolate chip Christmas cinco de mayo cobbler coconut coconut milk coffee cake cookbook cookie bars cookies cooking by the seasons copyright cornbread cornmeal cottage pie crackers cranberries cupcakes dairy-free detox diet dinner dinner ideas dip disclaimer donuts easy ebook eggplant eggs enchiladas eye candy Farmers Market fish flatbread food allergies frittata fruit crisp game day ginger gluten free goddess gluten free pancakes gluten free recipes gluten free soup gluten-free baking gluten-free baking mixes gluten-free bloggers list gluten-free meatloaf gluten-free oats gluten-free pesto gluten-free salad dressing gluten-free soup gluten-free vegetarian grain-free grains granola green chile guacamole help holidays hospital how to how to live gluten-free hummus humor ice cream irish soda bread Italian kale latkes lemon life los angeles love love foods low sugar mac n cheese marriage meatballs meatless monday meatloaf Mediterranean Diet mother's day muffins New Mexico New Mexico Inspired Newsweek no xanthan gum paleo pancakes party pasta peach peaches peanut butter pesto picnic recipes pie pineapple pizza polenta popsicles potato potato salad potatoes privacy policy pumpkin quiche quick bread quinoa quinoa bars quinoa flakes raw recipes rhubarb rice risotto roasted vegetables rolls salad salad dressings salmon salsa Santa Fe Santa Monica sauce sausage scones shepherd's pie shepherds pie shrimp side dish slow cooker smoothie snacks snow soda bread soup squash stew stir-fry strawberry stuffing substitutions sugar-free summer soup sweet potato tea bread Thanksgiving tips today's recipe tomatoes top ten travel turkey vaccine vanilla vegan vegan ice cream vegan pesto vegan recipe vegetable vegetarian waffles whole grain whole grains winter yeast-free bread zucchini
false
ltr
item
Gluten-Free Goddess®: Best Gluten Free Brownie Mix- Taste Test Update
Best Gluten Free Brownie Mix- Taste Test Update
Best gluten-free brownie from a mix. Our taste test. Who won? Here are the winners.
http://photos1.blogger.com/blogger2/6048/2353/1600/BestGFBrownie2.jpg
Gluten-Free Goddess®
http://glutenfreegoddess.blogspot.com/2005/12/best-gluten-free-brownie-mix-taste.html
http://glutenfreegoddess.blogspot.com/
http://glutenfreegoddess.blogspot.com/
http://glutenfreegoddess.blogspot.com/2005/12/best-gluten-free-brownie-mix-taste.html
false
19281824
UTF-8
Not found VIEW ALL Read more Reply Cancel reply Delete By Home PAGES POSTS View All YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE LABEL ARCHIVE SEARCH ALL POSTS Not found Back Home Sunday Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat January February March April May June July August September October November December Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec just now 1 minute ago $$1$$ minutes ago 1 hour ago $$1$$ hours ago Yesterday $$1$$ days ago $$1$$ weeks ago more than 5 weeks ago Followers Follow THIS CONTENT IS PREMIUM Please share to unlock Copy All Code Select All Code All codes were copied to your clipboard Can not copy the codes / texts, please press [CTRL]+[C] (or CMD+C with Mac) to copy